Stephen Bagley – Immigrant, Civil War Veteran and long time Plymouth In. Resident – by Douglas Bagley
My Great Grandfather Stephen Bagley was born in the Alsace-Lorraine Region of France in December of 1843, his parents were John (1814) and Magdelina Juter (1810). Stephen and his older brother Thiobold (SP?) (1841) along with their parents immigrated to the United States in 1848, it is not clear if a 3rd child Frances was born in the United States or France in 1848. We know the family can be found in the 1850 US Census living in District 135 Washington township, Stark County Ohio which is Northeast of Canton Ohio and and Southeast of Akron. John’s occupation is listed as a Weaver in this same Census.
The next item we have concerning Stephen is he was drafted into the US Army, 19th Ohio Co. H on October 8th 1862, at the time he was still living in Stark County Ohio. He was mustered in on November 8th, 1862 at Camp Mansfield Ohio for a period of 9 months. He was 18 when mustered into the army, was 5’5″ tall, had black hair, grey eyes and is listed as a farmer.
There is no record if Stephen ever saw any fighting while he was in the Army, his Unit figured heavily in the Battle of Stone’s River in TN. but the documents above seems to indicate he was located at an Army Hospital in Bowling Green KY during this engagement. He would have been with the 19th during the beginning phases of the Chattanooga TN campaign, but again nothing in the records indicates any engagements he may of participated in.
We do know that he was discharged from the Army July 24th, 1863 at McMinnville, Tn which Southeast of Murfreesboro.
It appears instead of going back to Ohio, he traveled with an Army buddy Casimere Wickey to Plymouth In, were he marries Louisa Wickey on June 18, 1868 in Plymouth.
Stephen and Louisa would have 6 children, 5 girls and 1 boy; Justine, Maria Magdalene (1869), Maria Louisa (1871), Christina Anna Eva (1873), Johannes “John” (1874), Mary (1877). Of the Children I know that John would pass away in Milwaukee, not sure of the date. Justine would marry a Robert Schoeniebe and Mary would marry a Buckley(?).
Louisa would pass away in 1879 from consumption.
Stephen would then marry Mary Kruyer who was born in Holland, in Chicago about 1880, they would have 2 children both girls: Mary(?) (1881) and Maria “Lena” (1885), again I do not have any information on these children. I did hear of talk of “Chicago” Aunts, but I have no details at this time, it could be the girls from his 1st marriage ended up in Chicago also.
Mary would pass away in 1889 and for the second time Stephen would be widower.
On August 27,1891, Stephen married for a 3rd time to Margaret Roth an immigrant from Germany (my note have Munich, but not sure if correct?), I have her arriving in the US on June 18, 1890. Family legend has Margaret seeing Stephen working as a Carpenter on house and declaring she was going to marry him. Margaret was my Great Grandmother. Stephen and Margaret would have 4 children, Edward Aloysius (1892), Elizabeth “Lizzie” Gertrude (1894), Joseph Peter Bagley (1896) and Francis (Frank) Bernard (1899). All the boys would end up in the Plymouth In. area and have families of their own, Elizabeth would become a Nun and would run the St. Mary’s bookstore for many years (while not being a Nun another Bagley would end up running a bookstore for another Catholic University).
Below is a pictures which is said to be Stephen Bagley, based on the bike, I would say this was took in the late 1880 of through the 1890s.
Stephen would work in Plymouth through the years, we know he worked as both a Bartender and a Carpenter around town. Another Family Legend has Stephen closing up a Bar and on his way home is attacked with an iron bar across his face and the bar money was taken, what was different is that whoever did this deed picked Stephen up and carried him to Stephen and Margaret house located on 1100 North Walnut St. and left him on the front porch. It was reported lost and eye in this attack.
Stephen built the house at 1100 North Walnut St with his own hands, the house is still owned by a descendent of Stephen and Margaret.
Below in a picture of Margaret

Stephen would die on September 30, 1903, Margaret would not follow until September 18, 1954. When Stephen died he left 4 childern with his widow.
If you know or have any other information on Stephen please contact me so I can include it in the family history.













